[ April 19, 2024 ]
Hoda Muthana, bride of ISIS terrorists, seeks a Court’s decision: Whether Muthana may claim birthright citizenship, and if so, a right to return to the United States. After a hearing on March 4, 2019,” the Hon. Reggie B. Walton, District Court Judge denied Plaintiff’s “Motion for Expedited Consideration.” The decision concerns only the pace, not the merits, of the lawsuit.
This is a power play between the Courts, Congress and the U.S. President, whose first priority is security of citizens. The government’s policy should be to deny citizenship to, or a right of return by, anyone who provides material support to a terrorist organization.
Muthana’s claims:
Story continues below advertisement
A lawsuit for expedited relief, filed on February 21, 2019, seeks to compel the United States government’s assistance to facilitate the repatriation of a U.S. citizen from Syria.
Ahmed Ali Muthana’s status as a diplomat for Yemen terminated on June 2, 1994, at the United Nations, located in the State of New York. His daughter, Hoda Ahmed Muthana, was born on Oct. 28, 1994, and her birth was registered in the State of New Jersey. Each parent subsequently became naturalized U.S. citizens, and relocated to the State of Alabama. Hoda was issued a U.S. passport on January 24, 2005; and it was re-issued on February 21, 2014. Hoda traveled from the United States to Syria to join ISIS in November, 2014.
Hoda Muthana’s father seeks “a declaratory judgment finding that he will not be in violation of 2339B if he provides his daughter and grandson with financial support to aid their survival and return to the United States.”
Hoda Muthana seeks “injunctive relief preventing the United States government from unconstitutionally robbing them of their rights as United States citizens, as well as a writ of mandamus instructing the United States government to uphold its duties to these two United States citizens.”
Their attorney seeks a finding that “the U.S. government has an obligation to assist in the return of its citizens from areas of armed conflict, based on U.S. law regarding the rights of citizenship, applicable international law, and the United States’ own [sic] publically stated policies regarding the repatriation of American citizens.”
It is alleged that Hoda Muthana “is prepared and willing to surrender to any charges the United States Justice Department finds appropriate and necessary; she simply requires the assistance of her government in facilitating that return for herself and her young son.”
USA’s response
U.S. President Donald Trump instructed the Secretary of State to deny entry by Hoda Muthana. The decision was posted on President Trump’s Twitter account:
The U.S. State Department issued a press release on February 20, 2019: “Ms. Hoda Muthana is not a U.S. citizen and will not be admitted into the United States. She does not have any legal basis, no valid U.S. passport, no right to a passport, nor any visa to travel to the United States. We continue to strongly advise all U.S. citizens not to travel to Syria.”
In its Memorandum, the U.S. government explains the officially recognized date of termination of diplomatic status of the Plaintiff, Ahmed Ali Muthana: “Settled law applied to the relevant events clearly demonstrates that Plaintiff enjoyed diplomatic-agent-level-immunity until February 6, 1995–after Muthana’s birth.”
“Thus, Muthana was not subject to the jurisdiction of the United States when she was born, by virtue of her parents’ enjoyment of diplomatic-agent-level immunity. So she did not and could not have acquired U.S. citizenship at birth. Because Muthana is not a citizen, every claim seeking relief for her fails.”
The “equities in this case defeat any claim for emergency relief—injunctive, declaratory, or mandamus—or for expedited treatment. Most fundamentally, Muthana’s own actions belie any claim for emergency equitable relief or for expedited treatment. The circumstances underlying the alleged need for expedited relief or consideration—Muthana’s alleged internment by Kurdish forces in Syria—are a result of Muthana’s own decision to travel abroad to join a foreign terrorist organization.”
Hoda Muthana’s passport was revoked because it was based on an error of citizenship: “Muthana was advised that she was not a U.S. citizen over three years ago—in January 2016—but she did not challenge that determination then and her father has waited until now to challenge it and to seek expedited treatment.”
“Muthana would have understood this unchallenged determination that she was not a U.S. citizen when she gave birth to her son abroad, and his circumstance is like that of any child born abroad to a non-citizen. To the extent that there are any plausible exigencies, they are of Muthana’s own creation.”
There is “no judicially enforceable duty of the United States to attempt to obtain the release of Muthana or her son—even if she were a U.S. citizen. Plaintiff’s request for an order of release from foreign military custody is far beyond any relief that could be ordered by a court.”
Analysis
Hamas–CAIR, a terrorist organization, provided a pro bono attorney, so that Hoda Muthana, a Muslim woman who gave material support to terrorists, can argue her claim of entitlement to be admitted into the United States. Florida CAIR director, Hassan Shibly, compared forgiveness of Confederate soldiers to Hodi Muthana’s return, and retweeted a story from the Baltimore Sun.
Is Hoda Muthana a U.S. citizen? This argument reiterates the absurdity of alleged birthright citizenship by virtue of persons who subsequently sought permanent residency status.
Hoda Muthana renounced her citizenship, and decided to not return to the United States, as illustrated by Hoda’s intent to burn her U.S. passport. Hoda reportedly was the owner of a Twitter account on December 1, 2014; but the account subsequently was suspended:
Hoda Muthana supported ISIS’ pursuit of a Caliphate. Hoda was aware of the brutal violence and murder of the unbelieving Kufar. Her tweet includes Alhamdulillah: Praise be to Allah.
The Middle East Media Research Institute provides more examples of Hoda Muthana’s social media:
The allegation that ISIS had control of her account is disproved by her personal entries, including this tweet, dated March 18, 2015, concerning martyrdom: “May Allah accept my husband, Abu Jihad al Australi. Promised Allah and fought in the front lines until he obtained shahadah.”
Hoda Muthana willingly provided support, aid and comfort to ISIS. Muthana knew her role at least would be a bride, two or three times, to the Mujahideen, warriors of the faith. It is argued that, because Islamic Iddah requires four months between marriages, Hoda had several periods to reconsider her support of ISIS or any attempt to return to the United States.
Only due to ISIS’ failure to establish a Caliphate does Hoda Muthana want to return to the United States.
If Hoda Muthana returns to the United States, she should be charged with providing material support to a terrorist organization. If so, her defense counsel likely will attempt to negotiate probation, such as a speaking tour for moderate Islam. Yet, Hoda Muthana likely will not renounce the Islamic doctrine: (a) Convert to Islam; or (b) become a second class citizen and pay Jizya, a tax; or (c) die. If Hoda is sentenced to prison, will she promote Jihad to inmates? Will criminal justice reform be used to reduce her sentence? Will a Democratic President pardon her?
If Hoda Muthana and her child return to the United States, they likely will be subsidized by taxpayers: SNAP (food stamps); Medicaid; and other comforts. Have taxpayers learned a lesson from the Tsarnaev brothers? Hoda’s child likely will be educated by Imams to pursue Jihad. The child likely will avenge the father’s death, perceived to be caused by American infidels.
Conclusion
Middle East immigrants are not terrorists, just refugees: A better life sought by women and children. That argument was promoted by President Obama’s administration, whose immigration policy preferred Muslims over Jews and Christians, arguably the real persecuted minorities by Islamists.
In this case, defense counsel with a straight face tries to describe Hoda Muthana as a refugee from an area of armed conflict. Reality check: Hoda Muthana provided material support to ISIS, a terrorist organization, in this holy war.
Hoda Muthana subscribes to political Islam, whose goal is a Caliphate to rule over the entire Earth. Islamists demand submission by the unbelieving Kufar. If you dare to be an Islamic “denier,” your punishment is death under Sharia law. A moderate Muslim must confess this doctrine, or be an Apostate.
The United States was founded upon Judeo-Christian principles, and a republican form of government. Our Constitution’s Bill of Rights is inconsistent with Sharia law. Therefore, Islamists construe Americans as Kufar, and an enemy called the Great Satan.
Is the claim of remorse genuine by Hoda Muthana, or actually Islamic Taqiyya: Lying to Infidels? Is Hoda’s return actually subterfuge so that she can promote Jihad against Americans?
Security of citizens is the first priority of the U.S. President and Congress. The government’s policy should be to deny citizenship to, or a right of return by, anyone who provides material support to a terrorist organization.
Read Hoda Muthana’s pleadings:
Read the USA’s pleadings:
Termination of Diplomatic Status
Gerald Lostutter is a Florida licensed attorney, college professor, journalist, and patriot life member (endowment level) of the National Rifle Association. This article does not create an attorney-client relationship. You should consult a licensed attorney for advice.
The Truth Must be Told
Your contribution supports independent journalism
Please take a moment to consider this. Now, more than ever, people are reading Geller Report for news they won't get anywhere else. But advertising revenues have all but disappeared. Google Adsense is the online advertising monopoly and they have banned us. Social media giants like Facebook and Twitter have blocked and shadow-banned our accounts. But we won't put up a paywall. Because never has the free world needed independent journalism more.
Everyone who reads our reporting knows the Geller Report covers the news the media won't. We cannot do our ground-breaking report without your support. We must continue to report on the global jihad and the left's war on freedom. Our readers’ contributions make that possible.
Geller Report's independent, investigative journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce. But we do it because we believe our work is critical in the fight for freedom and because it is your fight, too.
Please contribute here.
or
Make a monthly commitment to support The Geller Report – choose the option that suits you best.
Quick note: We cannot do this without your support. Fact. Our work is made possible by you and only you. We receive no grants, government handouts, or major funding.Tech giants are shutting us down. You know this. Twitter, LinkedIn, Google Adsense, Pinterest permanently banned us. Facebook, Google search et al have shadow-banned, suspended and deleted us from your news feeds. They are disappearing us. But we are here.
Subscribe to Geller Report newsletter here— it’s free and it’s essential NOW when informed decision making and opinion is essential to America's survival. Share our posts on your social channels and with your email contacts. Fight the great fight.
Follow Pamela Geller on Gettr. I am there. click here.
Follow Pamela Geller on Trump's social media platform, Truth Social. It's open and free.
Remember, YOU make the work possible. If you can, please contribute to Geller Report.
Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.
We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spammy or unhelpful, click the - symbol under the comment to let us know. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.
If you would like to join the conversation, but don't have an account, you can sign up for one right here.
If you are having problems leaving a comment, it's likely because you are using an ad blocker, something that break ads, of course, but also breaks the comments section of our site. If you are using an ad blocker, and would like to share your thoughts, please disable your ad blocker. We look forward to seeing your comments below.
41 Comments
5 years ago
The liberals will be believe she is returning from Disneyland! Ask her how many Yazidi slaves the trash had and what happened to them?
5 years ago
Reply to
jkarna
The jihadi whore needs to find a new home with her jihadi son.
Had the war raged on, she’d be perfectly content to be there marrying her fourth jihadi husband and having more kids.
5 years ago
Reply to
jkarna
Agree. Left/Liberal pro-jihadis/anti-nationals are corrupt paid shills for islam . paid by saudi/qatar/OIC
Merkel govt funded Pro-jihadi Left/Liberals run propaganda to create more sex slaves out of little children like in UK https://tinyurl.com/yd9jo5mf
Do these scumbags have any conscience ?
5 years ago
The Ikhwan Lite Party (oops, the Dem0rats) want her back in time for the 2020 presidential election…
5 years ago
Her child is not a citizen either. We don’t want either one of them.
Had Trump not cleaned up Syria, she’d be perfectly content to tweet jihad here.
This whore would have happily married her FOURTH JIHADI “husband” at age 24.
Mind you she freely left when she was 19 years old while others, adults at age 18 signed up to FIGHT the jihadis.
Maybe her parents should go live in Syria with her or return to Yemen where they belong.
NOW we are supposed to be worried about HER SAFETY in a refugee camp – LOL!!
A judge struck down expediting the request of her family to get her HERE.
Judge strikes down request to expedite case of ISIS bride Hoda Muthana
Greg Norman By Greg Norman | Fox News 3/5/19
…
Prior to the hearing Monday, attorneys representing Pompeo – who is named in Muthana lawsuit – insisted in a new filing that she is not an American citizen. Muthana’s citizenship status is one of the key disputes between the two sides. Her attorneys contend Muthana is an American citizen and that she and her young child should be allowed to return to the U.S.
“Those claims are profoundly flawed because Muthana is not and has never been a U.S. citizen, and her son likewise is not a U.S. citizen,” Pompeo’s legal team wrote in the filing, obtained by Fox News.
“She was born to parents who enjoyed diplomatic-agent-level immunity at that time of her birth, so she was born not subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, and did not and could not acquire U.S. citizenship at birth,” it continues.
ISIS BRIDE IS ‘WILLING TO PAY HER DEBTS’, LAWYER SAYS, WHILE CRITICS SAY ‘JIHADISTS HAVE NO SPACE’ (LOL)
The filing also pushed back against demands from Muthana’s team for a judge to expedite the case, arguing that her current predicament is all her own doing.
“The government informed Muthana more than three years ago that she is not a citizen and canceled her erroneously issued passport,” Pompeo’s lawyers wrote in the filing. “Muthana — who was at the time a member of ISIS — failed to act timely in response to that notification, [and] remained in a war zone through hostilities for a period of years. Plaintiff should not now be permitted to turn Muthana’s own delay and acquiescence — not to mention her decision to join a foreign terrorist organization in Syria — into an emergency requiring special solicitude for granting her a speedy hearing and speedy relief. “
In addition to letting Muthana re-enter America, the lawsuit is also seeking a judgment that Muthana’s father is “entitled to send his daughter money to ensure the survival of his daughter and grandson, and enable them safe passage home, without subjecting himself to criminal liability” under U.S. law.
…
https://www.foxnews.com/us/hoda-muthana-case-pompeos-team-says-isis-bride-not-a-us-citizen-as-attorneys-face-off
5 years ago
Reply to
felix1999
Deport the father. Sounds like he supports terrorist. A daughter or son of mine would no longer be welcome in my home if they went to aid and screw enemies of my country.
5 years ago
As is always the case with these wretched jihadist supporting muslima’s, their over arching belief in their own superiority
leads them to pay great attention to their rights but not their obligations to the society they’re trying to undermine by violence.
Freedom is not the right to do as you want {that’s licence}, it’s the opportunity to do as you ought.
Fortunately, more people in UK who never thought much about such matters before have had their thoughts clarified by the Begum case. As all on here understand, these women are committed jihadists themselves but in more subtle ways until an opportunity arises to “live the dream” at others expense.
These people must be the last ones you “give an inch to” in the hope they won’t stretch it into a mile.
5 years ago
Please, do NOT come back, you made your choice, now deal with it.
5 years ago
5 years ago
We don’t want her, kid or whole rotten family! They are from Yemen- go back. If she sets foot on American soil again, she should be executed for treason.
5 years ago
Reply to
AZ gal
The question is why should that be so hard to figure out , and that goes for any other Traitor !
5 years ago
Reply to
Bill Kay
Western governments have gone soft- don’t execute for treason anymore, unfortunately. These jihadis deserve it more than anyone in history.
5 years ago
Reply to
AZ gal
With out a doubt you are correct the govt best rethink it`s program then because the soft approach ain`t making it .
5 years ago
F*ck her and the camel she rode in on. As a Vietnam combat veteran, this b*tch makes Jane Fonda look halfway patriotic.
Besides, the 13th Amendment protection of birthright citizenship was for the benefit of the newly freed slaves after the Civil War and not modern day raghead terrorists or traitors.
And if CAIR has its grubby mitts on things, there is your first red flag.
5 years ago
Allowing this muzzie scunt to return to this nation would be an insult to every American that has fought and died for this nation.
5 years ago
Reply to
Larenzo1
What the government should do is clean house of all sedition in the land , and rid our country of this plague that should not be here in the first place !
5 years ago
Reply to
Bill Kay
Would be a good idea to start with those new congress ladies who actually don’t even like America, let alone represent America.
5 years ago
Reply to
mztore
Only broken Brains could allow this type of garbage to even get into Congress , it is beyond belief what is worse is the powers to be are sitting around watching with the thumbs inserted in their Ugh Huh`s
5 years ago
Wherever she settles, the DNC will groom her to run for congress. She would be another member of the new Jihad Caucus which formed after the 2018 elections.
My personal preference is just to execute her and her family and feed them to feral pigs.
5 years ago
I for one would like to see her live out the rest of her miserable hate filled existence in some third world Sh*ite-hole of her own making.
Thanks to the Swamp any Judge hearing this will have a Chief Justice Roberts moment, where under considerable and visible duress, decide in favor of Muthana.
That will promote Judge X’s career and possibly save their own life, but do irreparable harm to an already stricken US.
Sounds terribly cynical, but until Trump puts these Swamp-Criminals behind bars, this is the world we live in.
5 years ago
I wonder how many innocent men, women and children she has already butchered? And, we are going to give her a second chance, this time inside our country? This woman is either a serial killer or an aider and abettor of serial killers? You could not find a better example of a person who should not be allowed to enter this country. Let her be a slave to the Kurds for the rest of her life. They will know how to deal with her.
5 years ago
Just what we need, another condescending Muslim with a supremacist mentality, demanding her way back into the U.S.
Questions: Where was her father when she left for jihad back in 2014? Was he desperate to get her back so he could protect her as any good father would? Or was she simply following regular family protocol by jumping a plane to the middle of nowhere and marrying a big, hairy, jihadi beast? Something tells me Papa knew all about the tuition-for-jihad strategy and gave it his hardiest blessing.
5 years ago
This JIHADIA WOMAN is not an American. She was born of two Ambassadors stationed in America. She is the citizen of the Ambassadors’ home country.
With the posts this woman made, IF she steps foot onto American soil, she should be arrested, charged with TREASON against Americans, tried and punished according too the Constitution and its SUPREME LAW of the LAND!!!
She CHOSE too GO. She CHOSE too marry killer jihadists. Let her remain in the land where her jihadist HUSBANDS were killed.
5 years ago
Reply to
Laddyboy
If people don’t like America, and if they hate the country, why do they come?
It often does not work out well, for example the Boston Marathon massacre etc.
Why do these people come. It baffles my mind. Why don’t they stay in their own country, and leave us alone?
I blame the left for all of this.
There are some who should never have been allowed to come and I imagine the future will show us many problems.
So much could be said that one must keep bottled up. It has stressed us so much. This was not well done by the left, imo.
5 years ago
Reply to
Tm.
I think they intend to take over.
Doing a good job of it so far. Since 9/11 over ONE MILLION Muslims have been imported to the USA!
See for yourself. It’s ALL here. https://wrapsnet.org/
5 years ago
Reply to
Tm.
@TM;
Their GOAL is the conquering of all nations.
Their goal is to be the only “religion” that is acceptable by the world.
Hitler stole the basic idea of DIRECTED HATRED from the mohamMADan CULT.
May their efforts all end with the biggest DISAPPOINTMENT that God, not the IDOL – allah, can give them.
5 years ago
Reply to
Laddyboy
If people don’t like America, and if they hate the country, why do they come?
It often does not work out well, for example the Boston Marathon massacre etc.
Why do these people come. It baffles my mind. Why don’t they stay in their own country, and leave us alone?
I blame the left for all of this.
There are some who should never have been allowed to come and I imagine the future will show us many problems.
So much could be said that one must keep bottled up. It has stressed us so much. This was not well done by the left, imo.
5 years ago
Why is everything so difficult for the West? I get it that our poor brains have been subjected to decades of propaganda, to state it politely, but now, many have begun to question what we have been told for so long.
What happened to “NO?”
Do any laws support our ability to hold ourselves together?
All this has been decades in the making. And still going on, actually having escalated, and if not for President Trump and others like him, there would not have been that 20% respite that we currently have.
How much insulting must we bear? End this charade. Do right by us, by your good citizens. Please.
5 years ago
The illegal charged with the murder of an Iowa girl named Mollie Tibbets now wants his trial moved to a city where there are more brown jurors who think it’s OK to murder white Americans — like the mohamet who re.
5 years ago
“Each parent subsequently became naturalized U.S. citizens”
The tree doesn’t grow far from the apple. Send them all back home…
5 years ago
Reply to
MAS
Why allow them to become any kind of citizen? They should never have been allowed to even apply for citizenship, let alone become citizens. As foreign agent diplomats, that means they didn’t have to follow American law. Kick them out to go be with their daughter.
5 years ago
“Each parent subsequently became naturalized U.S. citizens”
The tree doesn’t grow far from the apple. Send them all back home…
5 years ago
Tempest in a tea pot! A diversionary tactic to take people’s attention off this little fact. Pompeo and Trump have both signed off on admitting up to 22,000 mostly Muslim refugees to the USA in the current Fiscal Year. This is done through the UN High Commission for Refugees or the UNHRC! They come here from the refugee camps in Jordan and the Congo.
I have been posting this link for months and only recently on BB does anyone Up Vote it and I have no idea if anyone looks at it or bothers to open it and see what is going on. It is very specific and detailed. Tells where they come from and where they are going. I think it’s too late to do anything about it. The USA is finished as it once was. Islam and some form of communism will destroy and take over the government of the USA this century.
5 years ago
She wasn’t even a citizen, she joined ISIS and now she wants the U.S. to come to her aid?? I guess, she can’t put together why she’s being denied. Perhaps Trump should really show some compassion in this case: send her an expired pack of lean Farmer John bacon strips, personally signed by him “Not on my watch, bitch. Much love, D.”
5 years ago
Non of these traitors should be allowed back into any western country. They have already made their choice and previous citizenship should be null and void.
Let them wander the deserts like strangers and be shunned by all.
5 years ago
All those isis bastards parading in their trucks got their butts kicked and she married one of them. Keep her in a s hole
5 years ago
I don’t believe it is legal to revoke the citizenship of any anchor babies. That is what she is. Since she was a legal citizen, even without a passport or visa, there is still a birth record from a US hospital. Her father had been a diplomat, but resigned before she was born. I would feel obligated to take her back, but only because of that obligation.
Then, once back, I would arrest her for giving aid and comfort to a sworn enemy. Then put her in prison somewhere away from other Muslims. We would not want to radicalize her more than she already is.
She left this country to be a bride, she says. What that really means is that she would be sexually available for men who fought against our allies as well as ourselves. She could no longer be trusted again, and for her own good, she should stay in Syria and let them deal wiith her.
5 years ago
The SWINE provided Aid and Comfort to the enemy which subjects her to the Death Penalty.
I volunteer to provide the service free of charge.
5 years ago
If we let this evil woman and her incubus back in the country…..we are fur-reaking crazier than she is. She should be stood up in front of a firing squad. Short of that, let her rot in the Islamic turd pile paradise of her choice. Message to Muthana…..”Stay and live among your own kind, my dear…..and get your scumbag family to join you”.
