New York students instructed to debate exterminating Jews

89

[the_ad id=”90513″]

Forcing children to argue for genocide and annihilation is depraved and the very definition of evil. It’s child abuse.

343314161-Final-Solution-homework-assignment

Story continues below advertisement

The evil is compounded by the fact that there is no real diversity of opinion of thought. Can you point to anywhere in academia where opposition to jihad and sharia is debated and/or encouraged?

There is no discussion, no instruction, no education about the gravest threat to our freedom and Western civilization, but exterminating the Jews — yes, let’s talk about hat.

New York Education Commissioner MaryEllen Elia said she sees how an assignment asking students to argue in support of the Holocaust could prompt critical thinking.

Upstate New York students debate exterminating Jews

By Susan D. Harris, American Thinker, March 30, 2017:

The New York education commissioner defended a local teacher’s assignment asking students to argue in favor of exterminating Jews.  It sounds incomprehensible, but MaryEllen Elia, speaking in Syracuse, N.Y. (Onondaga County) this past Thursday morning, did just that.  It seems especially hideous, contemporarily, since that city’s Jewish Community Center has been under lockdown three times this year: twice for bomb threats and most recently for a vaguely described “threat of violence.”

The education commissioner was addressing an assignment given by a teacher in neighboring Oswego County this past February.  The teacher, Michael DeNobile, gave the assignment as part of the Oswego County CiTi/BOCES New Vision program.  According to local reporter Julie McMahon, the students were asked to “put themselves in a Nazi leaders’ shoes and argue for or against the ‘Final Solution’ to exterminate Jewish people.”

It seems that only two students were disturbed by this request.  Jordan April and Archer Shurtliff (neither are Jewish) are both seniors at Oswego County high schools participating in the New Vision program.  The program allows students to take college-level classes on the SUNY Oswego campus.  April and Shurtliff brought their concerns directly to DeNobile, higher administrators, and even the Anti-Defamation League (ADL).  The two girls’ goal was “to make sure no other student would be asked to argue in favor of killing Jews again.”  They also asked for the New Vision program to retract the assignment completely.  They were unsuccessful.  In exchange for their complaints, however, the entire class was given the opportunity to choose their own alternative project.  Only three students took advantage of that, including April and Shurtliff.

Education commissioner Elia held strong to her support of the assignment, citing critical thinking as the supposed learning tool, saying, “I think it’s certainly a question where you want students to think on both sides and analyze … which position a person is taking.”  Student Archer Shurtliff, in a separate interview, stated conversely that “it’s settled opinion[.] … [Y]ou can’t say that Jews deserve to die.  It should be a settled thing.”

Dogged local reporter McMahon posted the actual homework assignment on Syracuse’s online news website.  Eerily, it was stamped “Top Secret” in red at the top.  McMahon writes:

[the_ad id=”90513″]

The assignment itself notes that the point is “not for you to be sympathetic to the Nazi point of view[.] … Ultimately, this is an exercise on expanding your point of view by going outside your comfort zone and training your brain to logistically [sic] find the evidence necessary to prove a point, even if it is existentially and philosophically against what you believe,” the assignment says.

(Ironically, Oswego County is home to “Safe Haven Holocaust Refugee Shelter Museum,” which commemorates America’s only refugee camp for victims of WWII.  In 1944, nearly 1,000 refugees were housed in the army barracks there as “guests” of President Roosevelt.  According to previous newspaper reports, approximately 900 of them were Jewish.  Strangely, the words “Jew” and “Jewish” are apparently mentioned only once on the museum’s website.)

ADL education director Beth Martinez said the whole thing is “deeply troubling,” adding that students should never be given an assignment “that even hints at their [sic] being ‘two sides’ to the ‘Final Solution’ / Holocaust.”  Martinez said she was notified by Roseann Bayne, the assistant superintendent for the CiTi program, that the assignment was still being offered along with an alternative.

Martinez cited Common Core as a catalyst for pushing students to argue from a perspective from which they do not agree.  This sounds benign at first glance – until you see an example like this, where a student is asked to justify mass murder as part of a learning experience.  One can only hope such a thing would be outside most people’s “comfort zone” and remain there.

The fight is definitely not over for two 17-year-old girls who had the guts to take on a monumental task: teaching some seriously misguided adults that “critical thinking” does not mean abandoning all human decency at the schoolhouse door.

The Truth Must be Told

Your contribution supports independent journalism

Please take a moment to consider this. Now, more than ever, people are reading Geller Report for news they won't get anywhere else. But advertising revenues have all but disappeared. Google Adsense is the online advertising monopoly and they have banned us. Social media giants like Facebook and Twitter have blocked and shadow-banned our accounts. But we won't put up a paywall. Because never has the free world needed independent journalism more.

Everyone who reads our reporting knows the Geller Report covers the news the media won't. We cannot do our ground-breaking report without your support. We must continue to report on the global jihad and the left's war on freedom. Our readers’ contributions make that possible.

Geller Report's independent, investigative journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce. But we do it because we believe our work is critical in the fight for freedom and because it is your fight, too.

Please contribute here.

or

Make a monthly commitment to support The Geller Report – choose the option that suits you best.

Quick note: We cannot do this without your support. Fact. Our work is made possible by you and only you. We receive no grants, government handouts, or major funding. Tech giants are shutting us down. You know this. Twitter, LinkedIn, Google Adsense, Pinterest permanently banned us. Facebook, Google search et al have shadow-banned, suspended and deleted us from your news feeds. They are disappearing us. But we are here.

Subscribe to Geller Report newsletter here— it’s free and it’s essential NOW when informed decision making and opinion is essential to America's survival. Share our posts on your social channels and with your email contacts. Fight the great fight.

Follow Pamela Geller on Gettr. I am there. click here.

Follow Pamela Geller on
Trump's social media platform, Truth Social. It's open and free.

Remember, YOU make the work possible. If you can, please contribute to Geller Report.

Join The Conversation. Leave a Comment.

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spammy or unhelpful, click the - symbol under the comment to let us know. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.

If you would like to join the conversation, but don't have an account, you can sign up for one right here.

If you are having problems leaving a comment, it's likely because you are using an ad blocker, something that break ads, of course, but also breaks the comments section of our site. If you are using an ad blocker, and would like to share your thoughts, please disable your ad blocker. We look forward to seeing your comments below.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
89 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Suresh
Suresh
7 years ago

Ignorance is No bliss. These jihadis are so vicious they do not even spare Aid workers who help them http://tinyurl.com/p8rdp7w

And No, its not happening in pakistan/afganistan , its happening in America.

Jay Evens
Jay Evens
7 years ago

It is clear the people in positions of power are to stupid and incompetent to rule any longer! We the people must #riseup and remove all in office and confiscate their wealth to be used to build the country they have destroyed.

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  Jay Evens

Stupid it’s not enough to say. This “teacher” is criminally insane anti-Semitic bitch and fascist. If she needs this “dispute” and unsure about the “final solution”, she should read the reports from Nuremberg trial. There is a room for her.

Linda
Linda
7 years ago
Reply to  tatka150

tatka15- – Scary thought – this depraved teacher may know exactly what the Nazis did. Only a devious, hate-infested mind could come up with an assignment like that.

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  Linda

Agree! We have to fight against it NOW!
She is a typical Nazi.
Never again is NOW!
This story should be published and receive the media attention( I don’t mean the liberal media)
They should scream it from the roof tops.
What a bitch! She should go to jail for the hate crime.
Go away from our kids. Thank you for you comment, Linda. I think we have to create some blog, like “Stop Neo Nazis” or something like that. Antisemitism start blooming even in America. It was always common in Europe. I was born and lived there a half of my life. I know.

Linda
Linda
7 years ago
Reply to  tatka150

tatka150 – Sounds like you could write an EXCELLENT blog! Do it. And each one of us should write a letter of protest to the school – stand up for other people’s children.

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  Linda

Thank you Linda, but English is my second language and I could make some mistakes:)
I emigrated from the former Soviet Union almost 30 yrs ago, but still can chock sometimes:)
But since I have a “great” personal experience of the abuse and persecution from the state, I would be happy to share and contribute for this blog. I paid a high price for the great honor and privilege to become a proud citizen of USA- the best country in the world. A big part of my family perished in Holocaust and when I read stories like this I can’t tolerate it. I also like your idea to write the letters about this “teacher”. Would be great to get some suggestions. Best regards.

0349 JAT
0349 JAT
7 years ago

Maybe some critical thought should be given to what happens when the muzlums are finished with JEWS.
Don’t they know there is no room in the muzlum world for any non- believers.

Liatris Spicata
Liatris Spicata
7 years ago
Reply to  0349 JAT

Jat-

A Russian Jewish immigrant told me this joke.

An old Armenian gentleman was on his deathbed, surrounded by his family. Seemingly in a delirium, he kept repeating words like, “Take care of the Jews.” and “Protect our Jews”.

Finally, his elder son could bear no more. “Father,” he said, “why are you so concerned about the Jews all of a sudden? We are Christian Armenians.”

The labored final words of this family patriarch were,

“Because once they are done with the Jews, they will come after us.”

Maranatha
Maranatha
7 years ago

True.

IzlamIsTyranny
IzlamIsTyranny
7 years ago

Turkish muslums didn’t wait on anything or anyone to exterminate 2.5 million Armenian and Assyrian Christians — and neither did their Kurdish muslum compadres.

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  IzlamIsTyranny

But they don’t want to admit it. It was 100 tragic anniversary of Armenian genocide in 1915. Turkish government said it’s not true.

IzlamIsTyranny
IzlamIsTyranny
7 years ago
Reply to  tatka150

I’ve had a stinking Turkish muslum tell me the Armenian Genocide was a defensive reaction by Turks to Armenian Christian aggression. He stank like an ashtray because he smoked unfiltered Turkish cigarettes.

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  IzlamIsTyranny

Their propaganda and indoctrination are overwhelming. I’ve just heard today that they made the “Open houses” in 18 mosques and invited all “infidels” to show how peaceful and nice they live and pray. Unfortunately I’ve missed the information where exactly it took place. Somewhere in US. I’m sure there is some info online.

bob434
bob434
7 years ago

Absolutely disgusting- Trump should threaten to withhold funding- Start clamping down o n these disgusting liberal bastions of immorlaity

Hook
Hook
7 years ago
Reply to  bob434

Don’t threaten, just do it.

Liatris Spicata
Liatris Spicata
7 years ago

I could see this assignment being instructional, although I’d find it troubling to hear of students arguing in favor the proposition that the state should exterminate vast number of people- men, women, and especially children, who were of no use to the Nazis- based solely on their religious or ethnic affiliation,

I wonder what the reaction would be if the assignment were to argue in favor of exterminating Moslems.

Pray Hard
Pray Hard
7 years ago

It’s not meant to be instructional and you know it.

Mahou Shoujo
Mahou Shoujo
7 years ago

A progressive fool like you would try to rationalize institutionalized hatred of anyone.

Liatris Spicata
Liatris Spicata
7 years ago
Reply to  Mahou Shoujo

Mahou-

More of your mindless calumny.

Shove your miserable attitude up your ass.

Mahou Shoujo
Mahou Shoujo
7 years ago

Keep your sodomy to yourself.

Mahou Shoujo
Mahou Shoujo
7 years ago
Reply to  Mahou Shoujo

Potted plants like a spoon full of well rotted fecal material on occasion, it keeps their foliage soft and subtle.

Tatiana Covington
Tatiana Covington
7 years ago
Reply to  Mahou Shoujo

That would make Liatris a Klein bottle. Unfortunately, that cannot be done in three dimensions. You need four!

Mahou Shoujo
Mahou Shoujo
7 years ago

Definitely the bottle is completely empty with that one.

Tatiana Covington
Tatiana Covington
7 years ago
Reply to  Mahou Shoujo

I’m not sure if that would be true.

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago

You are an idiot. What are you doing here?

Marco
Marco
7 years ago

Jesus, Joseph and Mary! All of whom btw would be horrified by this!!!

Pray Hard
Pray Hard
7 years ago

I would be breaking desks and bones.

Maranatha
Maranatha
7 years ago

Whaaat?
Is this today’s news or 1942’s???
In USA??
Despicable to say the least…
.

Eu Wei Choi
Eu Wei Choi
7 years ago
Reply to  Maranatha

They are going to actually have STUDENTS ABSORB Nazi Jew HATRED
WHERE are the PARENTS?

RCCA
RCCA
7 years ago

I’m horrified by this educational exercise. This is not only disgusting, it is useless except for those looking to justify anti-semitism and have fantasies of being Nazis. All the reasons for the Final Solution came down to one thing: hatred of Jews. There absolutely was nothing rational behind the arguments for the Final Solution. Zero. How does that develop critical thought?

With a minimum of time I can think of a half dozen topics which are actually relevant in our society which students could use to develop their critical thinking skills, e.g. birthright citizenship, rent control, term limits, rationing end of life care, the science behind climate change, is abortion murder, should we abolish the death penalty, etc?

santashandler
santashandler
7 years ago

How much more of this has to happen before people demand enough is enough. So that schools never even contemplate such an assignment ever again. But first, Ms Elia and Mr. DeNoble should be immediately fired and given a lifetime ban from ever working in the education field again. The idea that this affords students the opportunity to think critically,.is not only a lie but, PROOF that indoctrination is part of the curriculum in many U.S. schools. Bravo to the two students who spoke up.. If students were given an assignment asking them to argue either in favor, or against slavery, how many minutes would it take before the school was over run with violent rioters.

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  santashandler

Exactly. Bitch should be prosecuted immediately. Parents should file the complain to school district and ADF

DemocracyRules
DemocracyRules
7 years ago
Reply to  tatka150

The ADF will do nothing.

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  DemocracyRules

Unfortunately you are absolutely correct. They will do nothing. But this cannot go unpunished. One way or another. Too danger.

knightsstrength
knightsstrength
7 years ago

A teacher and those doing nothing need to be sacked

The assignment should have been how to exterminate the teacher. Guess the teacher would have second thoughts about handing out any such assignments

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago

Great said!

weirdpeter
weirdpeter
7 years ago

Substitute any other race or ethnicity (except white heterosexual men) and “polite” society’s howls would be heard on Jupiter. The left is working its way towards ending Western Civilization in favor the return of the dark ages.

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  weirdpeter

What is really awkward that LGBT always support the Democrats.
If/when muzrats finally build their caliphate in Europe and G-d forbid in US, they will exterminate all of them on the day one. How stupid the libertads could be?

Hook
Hook
7 years ago

Let’s start up a school and teach the students about exterminating Muslims world wide. How would that go down ?

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  Hook

In this case hell will brake lose.

DemocracyRules
DemocracyRules
7 years ago
Reply to  Hook

Hook:
Right. It’s just an intellectual exercise….

Tatiana Covington
Tatiana Covington
7 years ago
Reply to  Hook

Hmmm, maybe… let’s do lunch.

Libby Taylor
Libby Taylor
7 years ago

How about discuss the relationship of the “progressive” left/3rd wave feminism and Islam and their total influence over the education system.

J Ian
J Ian
7 years ago

Who are these teachers?? How do they get jobs? I simply don’t understand. (vomit)

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  J Ian

Me too. Since our schools are public, and survive thanking to our property taxes (over the top and rising regularly), could the taxpayers have more/some control of the public school’s education? I’m sure we can request it. To see who is who in our schools and what’s their agenda. I’m sure we all would be very surprise in accordance with the awful facts I found even in this blog. Otherwise we all pay much higher price that we even can imagine.

deweyv
deweyv
7 years ago

They will not stop with the Jews dear lord we need to break up this united states and let this scum have the north and east and west coast if we are to survive

Liatris Spicata
Liatris Spicata
7 years ago
Reply to  deweyv

Wait a minute, Dewey. I’m from Washington DC, and I am here to help you! We need you peasants toiling joyfully in the provinces.

/sarcoff

Bubba
Bubba
7 years ago

it is probably being financed by a liberal jew, who really isn’t a jew at all, just a liberal, who eats matzah.

Dennis
Dennis
7 years ago

This article comes on the same day that I had a serious conversation over lunch about a recent action that involved the writing on the walls of a local high school of derogatory words directed at blacks and Jews with Swastikas and a call to kill them all. Our conversation included our observations that this kind of hateful conduct seems to be growing here in the states. The discussion raised questions as to why this was happening now and seemingly increasing in propensity, as none of us could remember so much of this conduct as we grew up. Sure, we all recognized that this type of hate has existed for eons, but we all agreed that it has become more common place today then we could remember years ago. Why? We all wondered! Has there been an influx into the U.S. that is generating more of that kind of hateful conduct? Have all of our institutions, religious and public, failed to promote tolerance and acceptance of all cultures that are active in the free world? Or has there been an increase in the promotion of hate directed against people of other cultures and races? None of us could come up with answers to these questions. The conclusion that we all reached is that our youth and future generations will face continuing horror, unless we all learn what being a good neighbor is all about and we act with tolerance, rejecting animosity. We all wondered why those of the Jewish culture have become the whipping people of this world, and why the blacks are looked on with such angry rhetoric. Neither of these people have done anything to deserve the hateful conduct promoted against them; yet, the hate patently exists. It has become the rule today to call anyone who one does not agree with a racist or bigot. Our own president is accused of being a racist/bigot, when it seems to me that all he wants to do is reduce crime and free this nation of criminals. The world has gone mad.

Brenda buruma
Brenda buruma
7 years ago
Reply to  Dennis

Sometimes I think I’m living in a science fiction movie. Muslims hate each other, look at the Middle East, what a mess. Look what happened to Lebanon, Afghanistan, Iraq and Pakistan once they became overrun with Muslims. Isis tells us exactly what they will do but the leaders that be don’t believe them when they say they’re sending terrorists into Europe. Look at Europe now, I’d never go there on vacation. Five years ago, but not now. It’s becoming a hell hole. Imagine France wanting to put a fence around the Eiffel Tower instead of curtailing Muslim immigration.
It only stands to reason that Canada and the US will be next.
Yet our prime minister wants more of these people. Before any leader agrees on such mass immigration they should research the history of those whom they allow into their country first. It’s only common sense. Hopefully I’ll wake up soon and realize this will have been a very bad dream, or should I say ‘nightmare.’

Dennis
Dennis
7 years ago
Reply to  Brenda buruma

Brenda, I share your concerns. I assume your are a Canadian, and I am also observing the painful and dangerous decisions that your countries leaders are making in opening your borders to a people who come into countries as migrants, but they bring with them a belief system that can, in and of itself, result in their being unable to assimilate into Canadian culture and accept others who are not of the Islamic world. As a student of history, I have observed that prior influx of immigrants involved people who placed their culture secondary to the culture of the of the country that they emigrated too. They were able to practice their belief system, but they also accepted as a priority the new countries culture and laws as their primary responsibility and became lawful and conscientious citizens of the new country to whom they emigrated. I have come to believe that Islamic believers simply cannot do that, thereby opening those countries up for conduct that is unacceptable to becoming a responsible citizen of the country to whom they have emigrated. That is the nightmare that has already proven itself to be occurring here and throughout the free world. Until our leaders recognize that reality, the floodgates will remain open to this very dangerous environment.

Brenda Buruma
Brenda Buruma
7 years ago
Reply to  Dennis

You say ‘until our leaders recognize that reality, the floodgates will remain open.’ I only completed grade 13 many years ago so do not consider myself well-educated. So why can I see what is happening and our leaders cannot? They’re more ‘in-the -know’ than I am politically. Do you think it’s money talking, more than our leaders not recognizing reality?
That’s why I feel like I’m in a sci – if movie. Very few can see what’s happening. The Jews are fleeing Europe, and Canadian and American universities are preaching anti-semitism. The UN has acknowledged Christian genocide in the war-torn middle eastern countries by Isis and not one country is trying to help them. Even the pope won’t help them, yet he’ll wash the feet of Muslim refugees.
When will this movie end?

Dennis
Dennis
7 years ago
Reply to  Brenda Buruma

The determination of intellect is not based on how long you went to school. In my opinion it is based on whether you think reasonably and are understand what right thinking is all about. As you express your thoughts, I am convinced that you are both reasonable and right thinking. The problem people like you and I face is that we are dealing with many who consider being politically correct as being paramount rather than face the reality that patently stands before us. Islam is using its propaganda to stultify those of us that recognize and face the reality of a world that is facing a very dangerous political belief system disguised as a so-called religion. Though I also believe that some of those who are Muslim may not be so wholly involved in their belief system as to preclude them from becoming assimilated citizens within the free world, I am afraid that they have allowed their belief system to be captured by the radical believers, and therefore should not be allowed in to free world countries, unless they can be vetted convincingly.

IzlamIsTyranny
IzlamIsTyranny
7 years ago
Reply to  Dennis

No one “captured” islum. It was evil, depraved, totalitarian and antisemitic practically from the get-go. The peaceful Jewish tribes of Saudi Arabia were slaughtered, enslaved or driving out by the f’ing muslums. Tens of millions of Hindus, Buddhists, Christians, Jews, Baha’i, Sikhs, Zoroastrians have been collectively slaughtered by f’ing muslums over the 14 centuries since its bloody birth.
Wake up, wake up and smell the coffee, wake up and smell the jihad.

Dennis
Dennis
7 years ago
Reply to  IzlamIsTyranny

While I recognize that Islamic history has been horrendously heinous and warlike over its approximate 1400+ years, and while I also recognize the considerable danger that their belief system represents, and I believe that no vetting process can weed out those who would become terroristic, I also recognize that short of a major world bloodbath against these people, nothing will change. That is why I am of the opinion, contrary to the ultra liberals, the Democratic party and the “snowflakes” that the answer lies in some policy that keeps them out of the free world countries. That is the simplest solution to an unresolvable problem, avoiding a world wide blood bath. Let them live in their own world, and be prepared to battle them when they try to invade ours.

IzlamIsTyranny
IzlamIsTyranny
7 years ago
Reply to  Dennis

Millions of Germans had to die to defeat nazism. There are already too many muslums and traitorous collaborators in dying western style democracies. Ultimately you’re going to have to kill muslums or live under Shari’a law because there is no peaceful solution to a totalitarian, antisemitic, fascist, violent, vile ideology except deadly force. At no point in islum’s ugly, bloody, totalitarian past has it spread to as many continents as it has now.

AR154U☑ᵀʳᵘᵐᵖ DEPLORABLE 2020
AR154U☑ᵀʳᵘᵐᵖ DEPLORABLE 2020
7 years ago

Sadly, a lot of fellow so-called Jews are all too eager to help !!!comment image

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago

They are the shame of the nation. Kapos

Philip
Philip
7 years ago

If you do nothing to stop this as this happens locally by you, it only makes it more likely that it will be violently resolved when it happens locally by me. Thanks, for nothing.

IzlamIsTyranny
IzlamIsTyranny
7 years ago

The school assignment should’ve include the muslum POV on the Final Solution — after all they still espouse it and it would be more multicultural and inclusive too.

R. Arandas
R. Arandas
7 years ago

Liberalism at its finest. Anything goes, right?

s;vbkr0boc,klos;
s;vbkr0boc,klos;
7 years ago

Teach them to think the unthinkable.

Lia
Lia
7 years ago

I’d say ‘sick’ instead of misguided. But I do not understand why such things go on: Mizzou set the example to parents and alumni. Parents and alumni do not understand what immense power they wield.

Amethyst_2012
Amethyst_2012
7 years ago

I hope the police will charge this teacher with a hate crime. And make an example of her.

conan_drum
conan_drum
7 years ago

Imagine the uproar if the word Muslim had been substituted, and deportation for exterminating.

On another point, not many people realise that the first victims of the Nazis were Germans, firstly political opponents and then inmates of mental hospitals, disabled people etc. This of course does not diminish in any way the horrors of the Jewish persecution.

Fred8512
Fred8512
7 years ago

Depraved old communist hag; extremely sick.

BeverlyD
Beverly
7 years ago

There is no argument that can condone the Holocaust.

Common Core also wishes discussion re:
Were those who threw the tea into Boston Harbor, Freedom Fighters or terrorists?
Were those who flew airplanes into the Twin Towers Freedom Fighters or terrorists?

While a teacher is not supposed to take one side or the other, unfortunately that is seldom the case. How a teacher sees a situation, is how an argument goes.

Is it any wonder patriotism no longer exist!

linda goudsmit
linda goudsmit
7 years ago

This is the horrifying epitome of Leftist moral relativism, and a deliberate attempt to persuade naive students to identify with Nazi murderers at the expense of Jewish victims – it is monstrous. NY Education Commissioner MaryEllen Elia fired from Hillsborough County, FL schools now oversees 3.2 million impressionable NY students. The Left is determined to destroy every shred of morality established by the Judeo-Christian values that built America. Once the Left succeeds in obliterating any remaining sense of right and wrong they can legitimize and substitute their own left-wing liberal narrative of political correctness, moral relativism, and historical revisionism – America will be George Orwell’s dystopian 1984. The Left-wing liberal lemmings who allow their children to be indoctrinated in this particularly vile and destructive manner are participating in dehumanizing, desensitizing, and destabilizing of their own children. Elia and DeNobile should be fired and banned from education permanently – the hypocrisy of their stated position is staggering: “This is an exercise on expanding your point of view by going outside your comfort zone and training your brain to logistically [sic] find the evidence necessary to prove a point, even if it is existentially and philosophically against what you believe.” Students were not assigned to expand their minds and consider the relative merits of exterminating blacks, exterminating Muslims, or exterminating homosexuals or transgenders – only exterminating Jews.

Raymond J. Kowalik
Raymond J. Kowalik
7 years ago
Reply to  linda goudsmit

So Very true

RevRoy
RevRoy
7 years ago

Maybe soon people will wake up and realize that the DEVIL is real !! Look around you.
Rev. Roy……<

RevRoy
RevRoy
7 years ago
Reply to  RevRoy

Hey Dorrie:
You are more right on than you even realize. Having lived 75 years on this planet, I can testify that the world today is not just “upside-down” or “Bizzaro” but totally evil and insane. A recent article by the head of the “American Physciatric and Phsycological Institute (or something like that) made the case that anyone who believes that one can ” cut this or snip that ” and change a man into a woman or vice-versa is clinically insane. With trillions of X or Y Chromosomes screaming that one is male or female, to deny this is truly insanity.
This world is the exact opposite of the one that I was raised on. When a student gets docked on an essay for using the word “mankind” because it is “sexist”, it is time to look up because “your redemption draweth nigh”. That is King James language for the Lord is coming and people better prepare to meet their maker. These corrupt end times were described 5,000 years ago…”as it was in the days of Noah, so shall it be in the days of the son of man”. I suggest that people study up on what it was like “in the days of Noah” and call on the Lord Jesus to save them from what is coming. All this is just the tip of God’s coming judgements.
Rev. Roy…..<

IzlamIsTyranny
IzlamIsTyranny
7 years ago
Reply to  RevRoy

Yep no such name as Jesus (or Paul for that matter) existed in the 1st century CE — because nowhere on the face of the earth was the English, Spanish, Italian or Portuguese language being spoken, read or written. Western Europe consisted of a bunch of illiterate barbarians living in mud huts…

IzlamIsTyranny
IzlamIsTyranny
7 years ago
Reply to  IzlamIsTyranny

And Greece. I guess you’re right Rome is/was considered Western Europe isn’t it? I’ll bet the classical Romans (and Greeks) didn’t think of themselves as having anything in common w/the barbarians of Northwest Europe though.

IzlamIsTyranny
IzlamIsTyranny
7 years ago
Reply to  IzlamIsTyranny

The Roman Republic wasn’t so bad, it was the Roman Empire that was really evil.

RevRoy
RevRoy
7 years ago
Reply to  RevRoy

Well Dorrie:
It appears that we are on the same page. I am certain that you will enjoy my website. We rescued 2,200 Jews from the war zone of Eastern Ukraine last year who are now living back in their promised land of Israel. Isaiah 49:22 is our founding Scripture.
Rev. Roy…..<.

Tatiana Covington
Tatiana Covington
7 years ago
Reply to  RevRoy

a1175 Cott. Hom. 235
Ures hlafordes to-cyme þes helendes iesu [ed. ihesu] cristes. [Cotton Homilies]

http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/101162?redirectedFrom=Jesus#eid

tatka150
tatka150
7 years ago
Reply to  RevRoy

They are Hitler possessed. Jail for the hate crimes is a good treatment and exorcism.

bannedquran20
bannedquran20
7 years ago

More haman’s coming out of the woodwork. These scumbags don’t get it and after more than 3,000 years of history concerning the Jewish people neighbor! Hey scumbags, The Jewish people and their homeland of Israel will be around until time (as we know it) itself cracks. So give it up scumbags. .

Wayne Ville ... a Deplorable
Wayne Ville ... a Deplorable
7 years ago

The ones to blame here are the members of the Union of Reform Congregations. These JINOS have voted for every fascist democrat for the past 50 years!

Bill Kay
Bill Kay
7 years ago

What should be done is deport the Fool`s in the Education dept that is allowing this crap to go on , better yet prosecute to the full extent of the law first maybe they wouldn’t have to be deported !

Pamela Olson
Pamela Olson
7 years ago

A mind must be absolutely devoid of emotion as well as depraved to find this a criticle thinking exsercise!! I mean good lord…that is like asking whether or a not a baby is a baby even if unable to live outside of the womb!! Or how about whether or not Islam should be chopping off hands? or keeping women from being valued as equal members of society…or how about throwing gay people from tall buildings? It’s all the same depraved thinking….but noooooo, this silly twisted holocoust denier account is the only thing this sick teacher could come up with for a criticle thinking exsercise/assignment. *smh

This is where parents and community members must step up and put this ‘common core’ bs in it’s place!! the trash can! No one with two brain cells to rub together can look at this assignment for anything other then what it is, a denier liberal fantasy and trying to get children to agree with that fantasy. *face palm…that is not teaching or educating…that my friends is indoctrination!

santashandler
santashandler
7 years ago

There is no rational reason for this. Almost as if NY Education Commissioner Elia is deriving some sort of sadistic pleasure out of the assignment and the resulting uproar. Like she is ‘getting off’ on it……

DemocracyRules
DemocracyRules
7 years ago

How about exterminating all Democrats? It’s just an intellectual exercise, after all…

DemocracyRules
DemocracyRules
7 years ago
Reply to  DemocracyRules

How about an ‘intellectual exercise’ about what should be done with teacher Michael DeNobile?

DemocracyRules
DemocracyRules
7 years ago
Reply to  DemocracyRules

HAS ANYONE NOTICED
That Pamela Geller is actually the REAL Anti-Defamation League? Without Pamela’s voice, who would stand up to these monsters?

ZXB4983
ZXB4983
7 years ago

I recall another school debated whether to genocide white people. I am not kidding. I forget the name of the school but I remember reading about it and it was black students arguing for it! Conservatives are not kidding when they say liberalism is a mental disorder. Can you imagine the outrage if conservatives controlled academia and were pushing for the genocide of anyone or having offensive debates like that pushed in the classroom. It would be all over the news and we would never hear the end up of it from the likes of CNN and other left wing media outlets. They would be rightfully condemning it big time but when it is one of their ideological own pushing this horrible debate you hear nothing but silence from the left or them saying it is good idea.

marlene
marlene
7 years ago

In MY school, we will instruct students to debate exterminating New York school teachers. Send them my thanks for their template!

Tatiana Covington
Tatiana Covington
7 years ago
Reply to  marlene

Now you’re talking.

Sponsored
Geller Report
Thanks for sharing!