Why don't they run pictures of the murder victims? Take it from someone who follows these terrible murders, pictures are rare. In the case of Amina and Sarah Said, they seemed know the fate that awaited them. They almost appear to be posing for their eventual end.
The devout murderers hatched their plan in May.
Canwest News Service Left to right:
Mohammed Shafii, Hamid Mohammed Shafii and Tooba Mohammad Yahya have been
charged with four counts of first-degree murder and four counts of conspiracy to
commit murder, Kingston police said at a news conference Thursday.
Family problems evident before Kingston killings National Post (hat tip Jane)
Kingston police said Thursday they are pursuing allegations the murders were
carried out as so-called honour killings, a homicide where the victim is killed
by their own kin for a perceived violation of a religious code.
In an interview with the Kingston Whig Standard, Diba Masoomi – a
woman described as Mohammad's sister – said that Mr. Shafia "believed his
daughter had dishonoured him and the family by having a romance with a young
Pakistani man in Montreal."
Joyce Gilbert, a St. Leonard, Que., resident and neighbour of the Shafia
family, said Zainab ran away from home for a couple of weeks a few months ago.
At issue with her parents was her relationship with a young man they did not
approve of, Ms. Gilbert said.
"It was during the spring," Ms. Gilbert said. "I don't know where she went.
Her parents could not accept it. But she eventually came home."
Ms. Masoomi, a resident of France, could not be reached for comment. But she
is believed to be the author of an e-mail sent out to various media outlets and
the Kingston police a week after the submerged vehicle was discovered.
The author of the e-mail obviously possessed intimate knowledge of the Shafia
family, including the fact that Shafia first married Mohammad in either 1979 or
1980, and then married Yahya in the late 1980s. Both marriages took place in
Afghanistan, where it is legal for a man to have more than one wife.
The author of the e-mail alleged Yahya "was the privileged one" because she
could have children.
"The girls were not allowed to go out alone, for example, neither to the
cinema nor to meet friends and they were not able to dress freely. [Mr. Shafia]
often criticized the influence of the Western culture on his family since they
were not living in an Islamic country anymore," the e-mail read.
Photo: This photo is said
to show Rona Amir Mohammed, second from left, and Mohammad Shafia,
centre, at their engagement ceremony in Afghanistan circa 1980. It was
emailed to the media by a purported family member. (Canadian Press)
On Friday, Quebec's Youth Protection Services confirmed reports that the
organization was involved with the family in the months preceding the murders.
"We can say that Youth Protection Services did intervene with the family,"
said Jocelyne Boudreault, a spokeswoman for the government organization that is
now taking care of Shafia and Yahya's three surviving children, besides their
Ms. Boudreault said Youth Protection Services was required to intervene in a
family matter months ago, but could not elaborate, citing privacy issues.
Whose privacy? The dead girls? Or the cover your ass cretins at Protection Services?
UPDATE: Despite the outward appearance of being a quiet family, there were signs of
conflict within Mohammad Shafia's Montreal-area home in the weeks leading up to
the murders of three of his daughters and his first wife.
When allegations of a sinister plot of inter-family homicide reached
the tree-lined street where Mohammad Shafia lived with two wives and
his seven children this week, the Montreal suburb of St. Léonard found
itself dragged into a convoluted narrative involving the death of three
daughters and their father's first wife, and accusations it was
triggered by the disapproval of the eldest daughter's love life and the
refusal to end an unhappy marriage.
In St. Léonard, the
family's cramped seven-bedroom home, in one of a series of identical
square triplexes running through the prominently Italian neighbourhood,
sat empty on Friday.
The stories that have begun to emerge
in the aftermath of this week's murder charges have been filled with
shocking revelations about the residents.
businessman Mohammad Shafia, 56, his wife Tooba Mohammad Yahya, 39, and
their 18-year-old son, Hamed, were charged for the June 30 deaths of
his three teenaged daughters — Zainab Shafia, 19, her sisters Sahari,
17, and Geeti, 13 — and a woman originally believed to be their aunt,
Rona Amir Mohammad, 50.
All were found in the family's Nissa Sentra, submerged at the bottom of a Rideau Canal lock near Kingston, Ont.
Thursday, police confirmed the woman found dead with the three girls
was Mr. Shafia's first wife. Her family members told CBC Radio's As It
Happens on Friday how she was caught in loveless, abusive marriage with
Mr. Shafia, but unable to convince her husband to allow a divorce.
Abdali and Diba Masoomi, who live in France, said Mohammad and Mr.
Shafia were married nearly 30 years ago in Afghanistan but she was
unable to bear children. About 10 years later, he took a second wife
and had seven kids, but would still not give Mohammad a divorce.
Abdali said he had urged his sister to go to the police, but her
husband kept her passport, wouldn't let her use the phone inside the [sic]
Montreal home and threatened her with beatings.
wouldn't be grieving today if our sister had accepted, to go see the
police," Mr. Abdali said through a translator from France.
was also reportedly growing in St. Léonard over a romantic relationship
19-year-old Zainab had developed with a young Pakistani man, of whom
her father disapproved. According to reports, Zainab ran away for a
couple of weeks during the spring and upset her parents.
Masoomi has said her sister overheard Mr. Shafia talking to his wife
about the idea of killing Zainab some weeks ago, and was convinced the
deaths of her sister and the three children were the result of an
In an email to police, she told authorities
Zainab had been beaten by her father and older brother and had received
death threats. She also broached the topic of Ms. Mohammad's desire for
"In Afghan tradition, only the husbands are
allowed to divorce their wives, which [Mr. Shafia] had refused to do
for my sister for 20 years," she wrote.
On Friday, Quebec's
Youth Protection Services confirmed reports that the organization was
involved with the family in the months preceding the murders. The
family's three other children, a 15-year-old boy and two young girls,
are being cared for by Quebec's youth protection services.
from Afghanistan, the Shafia family lived in Dubai for more than a
decade before moving to Montreal about three years ago. A spokeswoman
with the federal Immigration Department could not provide information
about the family's Canadian citizenship records, citing privacy
While not much is known about Mr. Shafia's
business dealings, he appears to have been a successful businessman
overseas and in Canada.
While the family continues to rent
their modest home in St. Léonard, he has said he is having a house
built in Brossard, Que., which will reportedly be worth $900,000.
to land registry records, he has purchased a commercial mall in Laval,
Que., for $2-million since moving to Montreal three years ago, paying
$1.6-million of the cost in cash.
He owns a real-estate
management company and another, La Gestion Amanat Inc., which imports,
distributes and sells clothing and household accessories and
In an email sent to Kingston police and leaked to the Kingston Whig-Standard, Ms. Masoomi alleged Mr. Shafia was planning to travel to Dubai and Afghanistan to sell some land he owned.
is believed that Mr. Shafia married Ms. Mohammad in either 1979 or 1980
and then married Ms. Yahya in 1988. Both marriages took place in
Afghanistan, where it is legal for a man to have more than one wife.
Mohammad Yahya's aunt, Zarmina Fazel, has denied the four deaths were
the result of an honour killing. She publicly aired her belief that
Zainab was abnormal and had intentionally driven the car into the
canal. She denied the parents had anything to do with it, calling them
kind and honest.
The three co-accused have been charged
with four counts each of first degree murder and conspiracy to commit
murder and are being detained in a Kingston prison. No charges have
been proven in court.
The Truth Must be Told
Your contribution supports independent journalism
Please take a moment to consider this. Now, more than ever, people are reading Geller Report for news they won't get anywhere else. But advertising revenues have all but disappeared. Google Adsense is the online advertising monopoly and they have banned us. Social media giants like Facebook and Twitter have blocked and shadow-banned our accounts. But we won't put up a paywall. Because never has the free world needed independent journalism more.
Everyone who reads our reporting knows the Geller Report covers the news the media won't. We cannot do our ground-breaking report without your support. We must continue to report on the global jihad and the left's war on freedom. Our readers’ contributions make that possible.
Geller Report's independent, investigative journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce. But we do it because we believe our work is critical in the fight for freedom and because it is your fight, too.
Please contribute to our ground-breaking work here.
Make a monthly commitment to support The Geller Report – choose the option that suits you best.